Read more
Winter sowing season has started — call us for stock

Winter Wheat Varieties: Choosing Between Renan, Tigre and Galloway

A field of winter bread wheat

In Central and Eastern Anatolia, sowing of winter wheat is largely finished; in the transition zones and the Marmara region, late October to early November is still sowing time. One of the decisions to make before sowing is the choice of variety. The answer is not a single variety name: the region where the field lies, how harsh the winter is, how late sowing has been left and who the wheat will be sold to all play a part. In this article we compare our winter bread wheat varieties Renan, Tigre and Galloway from these four angles.

The difference between winter, alternative and spring wheat

Before comparing varieties, it helps to explain what winter actually means here. Some wheats need a period of cold before they can shoot and head. Those with this requirement are called winter wheats, and those with none or very little are called spring wheats; the cold requirement is known as vernalisation. A review co-authored by researchers at the Bahri Dağdaş International Agricultural Research Institute describes this requirement as a mechanism that protects wheat from cold, and it is the reason winter wheats are sown in autumn in Türkiye.

Alternative wheats sit between the two. Because their cold requirement is low, they can head even in regions where winter is not harsh, and they adapt more easily to late sowing. A winter variety, on the other hand, does not head without going through winter; sown in spring, it can stay green without producing ears. This distinction is the first step in choosing a variety.

Renan: for harsh, long winters

Renan is one of the long-established varieties of the French breeder Agri Obtentions; it was registered in France in 1990. It is a distinctly winter-type variety, and its cold tolerance is at the very top of the scale. Because it has a vernalisation requirement, it does not head without going through winter; it is therefore not sown in spring and its sowing window is limited to autumn. We recommend sowing it during October in Central and Eastern Anatolia, and from late October to early November in the transition zones and the Marmara region.

Renan is a medium-late variety. It tillers strongly, has a sturdy stem and resists lodging; at 95-100 cm tall it also gives a high straw yield. The grain is red and large, the hectolitre weight is 78-82 kg and protein ranges from 13 to 16.7 per cent. Yields are 350-400 kg per decare under dryland conditions and 500-700 kg under irrigation. We recommend it for Central Anatolia, the western and eastern transition zones, Eastern Anatolia and the parts of the Marmara region that receive spring rain; it grows on lowland, semi-lowland and dry land alike. In France, Renan is also one of the varieties favoured in organic wheat production.

Tigre: early, drought-tolerant and with white hard grain

Tigre comes from the same breeder, but it behaves differently in the field. It is of alternative type and heads early; its drought tolerance is high and its cold tolerance good. In an early-heading variety, grain filling progresses before summer heat and drought set in. Combined with its drought tolerance, this makes Tigre stand out for the transition zones and for warmer regions with milder winters. Because its cold requirement is low, it can head even where winters do not get cold enough.

Tigre’s grain is white, hard and oval. It belongs to the “Anatolian White Hard Wheats”, a group the Turkish Grain Board (TMO) treats as first class. Its alveograph energy is 450-500, gluten 32-38 per cent, protein 12-16 per cent and hectolitre weight 75-80 kg. Its tillering is moderate, at 8-12 tillers; it stands 95-105 cm tall, with a sturdy stem that resists lodging. It shows moderate tolerance to powdery mildew and rust, and can be sown on lowland, semi-lowland and dry land alike.

Galloway: awnless ears and early heading

Galloway is a new winter bread wheat from Agri Obtentions, registered in France in 2023. At first sight it stands out for its awnless ears. Its stem elongation is calm, its heading early and its cold tolerance good. It is quite resistant to yellow rust and moderately resistant to brown rust and fusarium. On the other hand, it is susceptible to eyespot, a disease of the stem base. Because this disease causes more problems in fields where wheat follows wheat, we recommend sowing Galloway in fields with a crop rotation.

Galloway’s grain is hard; its alveograph energy is measured at 310-395 at a protein level of 14 per cent. The balance between yield and protein is one of the variety’s strengths. These figures come from trials in France; for how Galloway is likely to perform in your region, you can consult Emin Erdoğan.

Grain colour, hardness and the values buyers look at

The value of bread wheat starts with a classification based on grain colour and hardness. The TMO’s purchase scale for bread wheat is made up of red hard, white hard, other red and other white groups. Hard and dark-coloured wheats are generally accepted to contain more protein and to have higher protein quality. Keeping different varieties apart after harvest is also important to protect a lot’s class.

For the milling industry, the strength of the dough matters as well as the grain. One of the values that measures it is alveograph energy; it is written as W, and the higher it is, the stronger the dough. In Europe the top group of bread wheat is BAF, the class of “improver and strong wheats”, and all three of our varieties are rated in this class. In France, wheats in this class are mostly grown under contract with flour mills and used to strengthen flours.

Grain colour also has a field side. In a trial in Eskişehir, red-grained wheats proved more tolerant of cold than white-grained ones. Recommending red-grained Renan for cold regions and white-grained Tigre for milder regions is consistent with this observation.

Choosing for your field and region

Looking at the three varieties together, the choice rests largely on climate and sowing date. In Central and Eastern Anatolia, where winters are harsh and long, we recommend Renan for growers who can sow during October; its cold tolerance is high, and its strong tillering helps close the gaps that open up after winter. In the transition zones, in places with mild winters and in fields where spring may turn dry, the early and drought-tolerant Tigre stands out. For growers who want awnless ears or who farm under quality-based contracts, Galloway is a new option; with this variety we recommend paying attention to crop rotation.

For all three varieties the seed rate is in the range of 22-25 kg per decare, and the sowing depth is 4-6 cm. We explained how to adjust the seed rate to field conditions in our article on how many kilos of seed per decare, and what certified seed guarantees in our article on seed certification levels. How to count emergence after sowing and what to look for in the field over winter can be found in our article on emergence checks and winter damage.

Choosing a variety is a decision to rethink every season; when sowing is delayed or the field’s situation changes, the choice may change too. If you share your province, whether your field is dryland or irrigated and the date you plan to sow, Emin Erdoğan can work out the right wheat variety with you: +90 506 101 01 50.

← Back to blog

Which one suits your field?
Tell us your region and irrigation conditions, and our agricultural engineer will recommend a variety.
+90 506 101 01 50